How to Use EDA to Study the Effects of Immigration on Local Economies

Exploratory Data Analysis (EDA) is a powerful approach to uncover patterns, trends, and insights in data before applying formal statistical models. When studying the effects of immigration on local economies, EDA serves as a critical first step to understand the relationships between immigrant populations and economic indicators such as employment, wages, business growth, and housing markets. Here’s a structured approach to using EDA effectively in this context:

1. Define the Scope and Collect Relevant Data

Start by identifying the key economic variables that could be influenced by immigration. These might include:

• Employment rates (overall and by sector)

• Wage levels and income distribution

• Business formation and entrepreneurship rates

• Housing prices and availability

• Local GDP or economic output

• Public service usage and fiscal impacts

Simultaneously, gather detailed immigration data such as:

• Immigrant population size by region and time period

• Demographic characteristics (age, education, origin)

• Immigration status (temporary, permanent, undocumented)

Data sources often include government censuses, labor market surveys, tax records, local economic reports, and specialized immigration databases.

2. Clean and Prepare the Data

Before analysis, clean the data for consistency:

• Handle missing values, outliers, and inconsistencies.

• Normalize economic indicators for population size or inflation.

• Create categorical variables if needed (e.g., grouping immigrant origins by region).

• Merge datasets from different sources based on geographic and temporal keys.

3. Visualize Population and Economic Trends Over Time

Begin with time series plots to observe how immigrant populations and economic indicators have evolved in the local area. Visualizing trends can help identify correlations or lagged effects.

• Line graphs for population growth vs. employment rates or wage trends.

• Heatmaps to show changes in business activity by neighborhood.

• Stacked bar charts for immigrant demographics over years.

4. Explore Spatial Patterns with Maps

Since immigration effects often vary geographically, use geospatial visualizations to uncover local variations:

• Choropleth maps displaying immigrant concentration and economic variables by region or city districts.

• Bubble or dot maps representing the intensity of economic activity alongside immigrant populations.

5. Use Correlation and Summary Statistics

Calculate correlation coefficients between immigration variables and economic outcomes to identify initial relationships. Summary statistics such as means, medians, and variances provide insight into data distribution and inequality.

• Correlations between immigrant share and unemployment rate or median income.

• Comparing economic indicators between areas with high and low immigrant populations.

6. Segment Data by Demographic and Economic Subgroups

Break down data by relevant subgroups to detect heterogeneity in immigration effects:

• Age groups: Younger immigrants might impact labor markets differently than older immigrants.

• Education levels: Highly skilled immigrants may influence tech sectors differently from low-skilled workers.

• Economic sectors: Agriculture, manufacturing, or services might be differentially affected.

• Time periods: Distinguish short-term vs. long-term impacts.

Boxplots, violin plots, and grouped bar charts help visualize these subgroup comparisons.

7. Identify Outliers and Anomalies

Outliers in economic or immigration data may reveal unique local phenomena, such as areas with unusually rapid growth or decline. Investigate these anomalies to understand whether they reflect data errors, policy impacts, or unexpected economic shifts.

8. Analyze Migration Flows and Economic Mobility

Look at migration inflows and outflows and relate them to changes in economic indicators:

• Are areas gaining immigrants also seeing increases in new business formations?

• Does higher immigrant inflow correlate with wage growth or decline?

Flow diagrams or Sankey charts can visualize these movements.

9. Apply Dimensionality Reduction Techniques

For datasets with many variables, use Principal Component Analysis (PCA) or clustering to uncover latent structures that group local economies or immigrant populations with similar characteristics. This helps reduce complexity and identify dominant factors.

10. Summarize Insights and Formulate Hypotheses

EDA helps generate hypotheses for formal modeling. For example, if higher immigrant concentrations correlate with increased entrepreneurship but lower wages in certain sectors, future regression models can test these relationships controlling for other factors.

---

Using EDA systematically enables a comprehensive and nuanced understanding of how immigration influences local economic dynamics. It also highlights areas needing deeper investigation, guiding policymakers and researchers toward data-driven decisions.