How to Analyze Data with Missing Values Using EDA

Exploratory Data Analysis (EDA) is a crucial step in understanding the structure, patterns, and anomalies within a dataset before applying any statistical or machine learning models. When dealing with real-world data, missing values are almost inevitable and can significantly impact analysis outcomes. Properly handling and analyzing data with missing values during EDA helps ensure that subsequent analyses or models are more accurate and reliable. This article dives into effective strategies and techniques to analyze data with missing values using EDA.

Understanding Missing Data

Missing data can occur for various reasons—data entry errors, equipment failure, non-response in surveys, or data corruption. Before jumping into analysis, it’s important to understand the type of missingness present:

• Missing Completely at Random (MCAR): The missingness has no relationship to any other data or variable.

• Missing at Random (MAR): Missingness is related to some observed data but not the missing data itself.

• Missing Not at Random (MNAR): Missingness depends on the missing data itself or unobserved variables.

Understanding this helps guide the approach to analyzing and imputing missing values.

Step 1: Identify and Quantify Missing Data

The first step in EDA is to locate where missing data exists and measure its extent.

• Missing Value Counts: Summarize the number and percentage of missing values per variable.

• Visualizing Missingness: Use heatmaps or matrix plots to get a visual summary of missing data patterns across the dataset.

• Missing Data Patterns: Identify if missingness is concentrated in specific rows, columns, or randomly scattered.

Common tools for this step include Python libraries such as pandas (.isnull(), .info()), matplotlib, seaborn (heatmap), and specialized libraries like missingno.

Step 2: Explore the Impact of Missing Data on Variables

Once missing values are identified, analyze how they affect individual variables and the dataset overall.

• Summary Statistics Comparison: Compare mean, median, and other statistics between complete cases and incomplete cases to see if missingness skews data.

• Correlation with Missingness: Check if missingness correlates with other variables to detect possible MAR or MNAR patterns.

• Distribution Analysis: Visualize distributions (histograms, box plots) for variables with missing data, separating missing and non-missing groups.

This helps understand if missing data introduces bias or if certain groups are underrepresented.

Step 3: Decide on the Missing Data Handling Strategy

Depending on the analysis goals and missingness patterns, decide how to handle missing data:

• Deletion Methods:

  • Listwise Deletion: Remove rows with any missing values. Simple but may reduce sample size and introduce bias if data is not MCAR.

  • Pairwise Deletion: Use all available data pairs for correlation or covariance calculations, avoiding removal of entire rows unnecessarily.

• Imputation Methods:

  • Simple Imputation: Replace missing values with mean, median, mode, or a constant. Quick but can distort distributions.

  • Advanced Imputation: Use regression, k-Nearest Neighbors (kNN), or multiple imputation methods to better estimate missing values based on other features.

• Leave Missing Values As-Is: In some analyses, especially with models that handle missingness internally (e.g., XGBoost), it may be acceptable to keep missing values.

Step 4: Visualize Relationships Involving Missing Data

Visualization plays a key role in understanding how missing values interact with other variables.

• Missingness vs Target Variable: Plot missing value indicators against the target variable (if supervised learning) to check for systematic missingness related to outcomes.

• Scatter Plots with Missingness Flags: Introduce binary flags for missing data and visualize how missingness distributes across feature relationships.

• Pair Plots and Facets: Separate data by missingness status to compare feature interactions and distributions.

These insights help in deciding whether missingness carries informative value that should be preserved.

Step 5: Use Missingness as a Feature

If the pattern of missingness itself carries meaningful information, create binary flags indicating the presence or absence of data for specific variables. These flags can enhance model performance by capturing the implicit signal in missing data.

Step 6: Document Missing Data Decisions

During EDA, keep a detailed record of all findings, assumptions about missingness, and handling methods chosen. This documentation aids transparency and reproducibility, especially when sharing analysis or deploying models.

Example Workflow Using Python

python
CopyEdit
import pandas as pd
import missingno as msno
import matplotlib.pyplot as plt

# Load data
data = pd.read_csv('data.csv')

# Step 1: Missing value counts
print(data.isnull().sum())

# Visualize missing data
msno.matrix(data)
plt.show()

# Step 2: Summary stats with/without missing values
print(data['variable'].describe())
print(data[data['variable'].notnull()]['variable'].describe())

# Step 3: Impute missing values with median
data['variable'].fillna(data['variable'].median(), inplace=True)

# Step 4: Create missingness indicator
data['variable_missing'] = data['variable'].isnull().astype(int)

# Step 5: Visualize missingness vs target
import seaborn as sns
sns.boxplot(x='variable_missing', y='target', data=data)
plt.show()

Conclusion

Analyzing data with missing values during EDA requires a blend of quantitative summaries, visualization, and domain knowledge. Understanding the nature and pattern of missingness informs appropriate handling strategies that preserve data integrity and avoid bias. Whether imputing values, removing incomplete data, or leveraging missingness as an informative feature, a careful EDA process ensures robust insights and stronger predictive modeling.

Consistent practice of these steps transforms messy, incomplete data into actionable information for confident decision-making.