Designing observability per architectural layer

Designing observability across different architectural layers is crucial to ensure that a system is monitored effectively, that performance bottlenecks can be identified, and that errors or failures are detected early. Observability refers to the ability to measure and understand the internal state of a system based on the data it produces. This data can be captured through metrics, logs, and traces, often referred to as the “three pillars of observability.” Here’s how observability can be designed per architectural layer:

1. Presentation Layer (Frontend)

Key Observability Aspects:

• User Experience Metrics (UX): Monitoring user interactions, page load times, and responsiveness is critical. Tools like Google Analytics, Web Vitals, and RUM (Real User Monitoring) can help collect these metrics.

• Error Tracking: Client-side JavaScript errors should be captured. Tools like Sentry, Rollbar, or Bugsnag can help you track frontend errors, including unhandled exceptions, failed API calls, and rendering issues.

• Session & Performance Data: Observing how users navigate through the application can provide insights into which parts of the app perform poorly or where users face issues. Tools like Datadog or New Relic can provide real-time session tracking.

Implementing Observability:

• Implement error boundaries to catch exceptions in the UI and send logs to a central logging system.

• Use performance monitoring tools like Lighthouse to continuously assess frontend performance.

• Include client-side tracing for API calls, UI interactions, and other resource loading patterns. Tools like OpenTelemetry can help trace the lifecycle of a request from the browser to the backend.

2. Application Layer (Business Logic)

Key Observability Aspects:

• Business Metrics: It’s important to measure things like user sign-ups, payment success rates, or product usage statistics. These are business-level metrics that directly map to the value the application provides to users.

• Error Handling and Logging: The application layer is often where most errors occur, whether they are internal or external. Proper logging ensures that the development team can respond quickly to issues. Use structured logging and make sure that logs are clear, comprehensive, and indexed for searchability.

• API Monitoring and Traceability: Since most applications interact through APIs, monitoring the health and performance of these services is vital. Observing the flow of data through APIs helps in understanding where delays or failures occur.

Implementing Observability:

• Implement custom event logging (e.g., success and failure events for specific business actions).

• Use distributed tracing (e.g., OpenTelemetry) to track requests as they move between services.

• Integrate application performance monitoring (APM) tools like Datadog, New Relic, or Dynatrace to monitor transaction traces, identify bottlenecks, and alert on anomalies.

3. Service Layer (Microservices / APIs)

Key Observability Aspects:

• Service Availability and Uptime: Ensure that your microservices or APIs are up and running. Monitor the health of services using health check endpoints and response time metrics.

• Error Rate and Latency: Track the number of errors (e.g., HTTP 5xx errors) and latency for each service. A sudden spike in errors or latency can point to underlying issues.

• Resource Usage: Monitor CPU, memory, disk usage, and network usage on a per-service basis. This helps you identify if a specific service is consuming too many resources and potentially causing system instability.

Implementing Observability:

• Set up health checks to ensure that each microservice is responding properly.

• Use distributed tracing to see how requests move through multiple services, and implement a tool like Jaeger or Zipkin to visualize traces.

• Track service-specific metrics like request count, error rate, and response time via Prometheus or StatsD.

• Collect system-level metrics from the infrastructure to ensure that services have enough resources (CPU, memory, disk).

4. Data Layer (Database, Caching, Storage)

Key Observability Aspects:

• Database Performance: Monitoring query performance, slow queries, and connection pool sizes is critical for ensuring smooth database operations. Metrics like query response times, transaction rates, and database throughput are important.

• Data Consistency: Ensure that data integrity and consistency are maintained. Monitor for replication lag, data anomalies, or integrity violations.

• Cache Hit/Miss Rates: Monitor how effectively caches (e.g., Redis, Memcached) are being utilized. High cache miss rates can lead to unnecessary database queries, which degrade performance.

Implementing Observability:

• Use database performance monitoring tools like Percona Monitoring and Management (PMM) or New Relic APM to track slow queries and resource utilization.

• Track database connection pools and query latencies through Prometheus or Datadog.

• For caching systems, monitor hit/miss ratios, eviction rates, and latency using tools like Redis’ built-in monitoring or custom metrics.

5. Infrastructure Layer (Cloud/On-Prem Servers, Networking)

Key Observability Aspects:

• Infrastructure Health: Monitoring the availability and health of servers, containers, and virtual machines is crucial. Tools like Kubernetes’ built-in health checks and cloud provider monitoring (AWS CloudWatch, Azure Monitor) help with this.

• Resource Utilization: Monitoring the health of the underlying infrastructure, including CPU usage, memory, disk space, and network throughput, ensures that resources are not overutilized.

• Network Monitoring: Tracking network latency, packet loss, and errors helps to ensure that the infrastructure layer can handle the volume of traffic without introducing delays.

Implementing Observability:

• Use infrastructure monitoring tools like Prometheus, Grafana, and AWS CloudWatch to keep track of server resource usage and health.

• Set up network monitoring to track packet loss, bandwidth utilization, and network congestion.

• Use container orchestration monitoring (e.g., Kubernetes metrics) to track pod performance, pod restarts, and resource usage.

6. Security Layer

Key Observability Aspects:

• Access Logs: Security is not just about preventing unauthorized access but also ensuring that access patterns are logged for auditing purposes. This includes login attempts, permission changes, and API key usage.

• Intrusion Detection and Anomaly Monitoring: Monitor for signs of potential attacks, such as SQL injections, denial-of-service (DoS) attacks, or unusual traffic patterns.

• Data Encryption and Compliance Metrics: Track compliance-related data such as encryption usage, data access patterns, and audit trails to ensure that sensitive information is protected.

Implementing Observability:

• Use SIEM (Security Information and Event Management) tools like Splunk or ELK Stack to monitor security logs and detect anomalies.

• Track failed login attempts, unauthorized API access, and suspicious behavior via event logging.

• Monitor data encryption metrics and ensure that keys and certificates are up to date and being used properly.

7. End-to-End Observability with Distributed Tracing

Key Observability Aspects:

• End-to-End Tracing: To understand how an event flows through your entire system, implement end-to-end distributed tracing. This helps identify bottlenecks across different services, including frontend, backend, and database layers.

• Correlation of Metrics, Logs, and Traces: Ensure that logs, metrics, and traces are correlated so that teams can gain a complete understanding of system performance and errors.

Implementing Observability:

• Use OpenTelemetry or Jaeger to implement distributed tracing across all layers of the system.

• Integrate logs and metrics with tracing, so that when an anomaly is detected in a trace, relevant log and metric data can be pulled up for investigation.

---

By designing observability into each layer of the architecture, you can get comprehensive visibility across your system, helping you detect issues early, optimize performance, and improve overall user experience. Additionally, you can quickly correlate issues between layers, from frontend problems all the way down to database bottlenecks, making it easier to troubleshoot and resolve incidents efficiently.