Designing declarative service authorization logic

Designing declarative service authorization logic involves creating a system in which access control decisions are specified in a high-level, declarative manner rather than being tightly coupled to application logic. This approach provides clarity, scalability, and maintainability, as the authorization rules are separated from the core application code. Below is an outline of how to approach designing such a system:

1. Understanding the Basics of Declarative Authorization

Declarative authorization refers to specifying who has access to what resources and under what conditions, without embedding these rules directly into the application logic. This is typically done through policy definitions, which describe the rules governing access to resources in a clear and structured format.

In contrast, imperative (or programmatic) authorization hardcodes logic for access control directly into the application, usually within the codebase itself, which can become messy and difficult to maintain.

2. Core Components of Declarative Authorization Logic

A declarative authorization system generally consists of several key components:

Policies: These are high-level rules that define access to resources based on conditions such as roles, attributes, and context. Policies might be expressed in a domain-specific language (DSL), JSON, YAML, or other readable formats.
Roles: Users are typically grouped into roles that define what resources they can access. These roles could be user roles (admin, editor, viewer), but also more complex roles like “manager of a team” or “project owner.”
Attributes: Attributes refer to user-specific or resource-specific data that might affect access control. For example, a user’s department, location, or specific permissions tied to an object might be used to control access.
Resource Types: The system should be able to apply policies to specific types of resources, such as files, databases, or APIs.
Conditions: These are specific rules that further refine access, based on time, environment, or other context.

3. Steps in Designing Declarative Authorization Logic

Step 1: Define the Scope of Authorization

Before anything can be coded, it’s essential to understand what parts of the service require protection. This could include:

API endpoints
Database operations (read, write, delete)
Files and directories
Services or microservices

Defining these will guide how you create access control policies for each.

Step 2: Determine the Key Attributes for Access Control

Identify the key attributes that will be used to make authorization decisions. Common attributes might include:

User Roles: What role does the user have (e.g., admin, user, guest)?
Resource Ownership: Is the user the owner of the resource?
User Attributes: Attributes like department, region, or status can influence access.
Contextual Information: This includes things like time of day, location, or device type.

Step 3: Design Authorization Policies

Create policies that specify how access is determined based on the attributes. The structure of the policy can vary, but it typically has:

Subject: The user or entity trying to access the resource.
Action: What the subject wants to do (e.g., read, write, delete).
Object: The resource the action is being performed on.
Conditions: Any additional conditions that must be true for access to be granted.

For example, a policy might look like:

yaml
- subject: user
  action: read
  object: document
  conditions:
    - role: admin
    - department: finance

This would grant read access to a document if the user is an admin in the finance department.

Step 4: Select the Authorization Framework

There are several frameworks that can help enforce declarative authorization. These frameworks abstract much of the complexity involved in defining, storing, and evaluating policies. Some examples include:

OPA (Open Policy Agent): A policy engine that allows you to define policies in Rego, a high-level declarative language. It can be integrated into a service to provide fine-grained access control.
Casbin: An open-source access control library that supports multiple models (RBAC, ABAC, etc.) and policy storage backends.
XACML (eXtensible Access Control Markup Language): A standard for expressing authorization policies.

Step 5: Implement the Policy Evaluation Engine

Once policies are defined, you need an engine that evaluates them during each authorization request. The engine takes into account the user’s identity, the requested action, the target resource, and any context-specific conditions to decide whether access should be granted.

The evaluation process can be as simple as checking the user’s role or as complex as evaluating fine-grained conditions based on dynamic attributes. The engine should be flexible to allow adding new policies without disrupting existing ones.

Step 6: Decouple Authorization Logic from Business Logic

One of the primary goals of declarative authorization is to decouple the access control logic from business logic. This allows authorization decisions to be managed independently from the core service and makes the system more maintainable.

This can be achieved by using a centralized policy store (e.g., a database, policy server, or a cloud-based policy service) and an external decision-making engine. This way, when policies need to change (e.g., updating roles or conditions), it can be done without touching the core application code.

Step 7: Testing and Auditing

After the authorization logic is implemented, it’s critical to test it rigorously:

Unit Testing: Ensure that each policy is functioning correctly for different roles and attributes.
Integration Testing: Test the interaction between the service and the policy engine to verify access control across different parts of the system.
Auditing: Create logs for all access decisions, whether they are granted or denied. This allows auditing and troubleshooting later.

4. Best Practices for Declarative Authorization Design

Separation of Concerns: Keep authorization logic separate from business logic to improve maintainability.
Keep Policies Simple: Use simple, understandable language to express policies. Complex policies can lead to mistakes and make the system harder to manage.
Use a Standardized Language: Consider using an established policy language (like Rego in OPA or XACML) to ensure your policies are clear and maintainable.
Avoid Hardcoding Decisions: Allow policies to be easily updated without changing code. This can be done by externalizing the policies to a database or configuration file.
Scalability: As your system grows, consider how your authorization logic will scale. Declarative authorization is naturally scalable as you can add policies without affecting other parts of the system.

5. Examples of Declarative Authorization in Practice

Here are a few examples of declarative authorization rules:

Example 1: Role-Based Access Control (RBAC)

yaml
- subject: user
  action: create
  object: post
  conditions:
    - role: admin

Example 2: Attribute-Based Access Control (ABAC)

yaml
- subject: user
  action: read
  object: document
  conditions:
    - role: editor
    - department: sales
    - resource.owner: user

Example 3: Time-Based Authorization

yaml
- subject: user
  action: delete
  object: file
  conditions:
    - role: admin
    - time: after 9am and before 6pm

6. Conclusion

Designing declarative service authorization logic enhances security and maintainability by providing a clear, flexible, and easily updatable way to manage access control. By abstracting the authorization logic from business processes, you can implement a more dynamic and scalable system that is less prone to errors and easier to manage over time.

Share This Page: